The Family Meeting Every Hawai‘i Landowner Should Have

As in the movie The Descendants, local families are faced with the responsibility of choosing what to do with inherited real estate assets. Guest contributing writer Ray Tsuchiyama shares his experience as a Hawaiʻi real estate executive specializing in property portfolio strategy.
1126 Familyoffice Hero 2

Eventually, most multigenerational Hawaiʻi families hold the same meeting. It does not happen in a lawyer’s conference room. It happens around a kitchen table, or over Zoom with a sibling calling in from Seattle or Los Angeles, and it starts with a version of the same question: What do we actually do with everything Grandma and Grandpa built?

For decades, people took the answer for granted rather than discussing it. Hawai‘i built its wealth differently than the rest of the country – not through public companies or stock portfolios, but parcel by parcel, ground lease by ground lease. The rule handed down through generations was short and absolute: hold the land, do not sell.

That discipline created real fortunes. It also created a problem nobody planned for: what happens when the family members managing that legacy no longer share a single household, a single set of financial needs, or even a single time zone?

Why the Old Model Is Straining

Land is not liquid. It cannot easily cover an estate tax bill, seed a grandchild’s new business, or buy out a cousin who would rather have cash than a fractional stake in a property they have never set foot on. As ownership passes from founders to children to grandchildren, a single deed can end up split among a dozen or more beneficiaries – each with different incomes, different geographies and different levels of attachment to the asset itself.

Meanwhile, the cost of simply holding property has climbed. Construction and renovation budgets have risen steeply. Insurance is more expensive to secure. Property tax bills arrive larger in each cycle. None of this makes land worth less – but it makes the job of managing it harder, especially for a generation that may never have negotiated a lease or walked the property line themselves.

Some families are already responding. Ground leases across the state are being restructured or recapitalized with new capital partners. Agricultural parcels are being reevaluated for their highest long-term use. Mainland and foreign investors continue to view Hawai‘i real estate – including long-hold ground leases – as a stable, appealing structure, which gives local families more options than they had a generation ago, including exchanging into mainland assets entirely.

A Different Question to Start With

When a family gathers to talk about their real estate, the instinct is to start with valuation: What is each property worth today? That is the wrong starting question. The right one is: What job is each property actually doing for this family?

Picture a family holding a neighborhood retail center in growing Kapolei, a minority stake in a Kaka‘ako residential project, and a cattle ranch on the Big Island passed down from a grandparent. On paper, these are three real estate investments. In practice, they serve entirely distinct roles – one produces steady rental income the family depends on, one is a growth bet with real upside and real risk, and one is inseparable from the family’s identity and has never been viewed as a financial asset at all.

Treating all three the same way – hold everything, forever, by default – misses the point. The retail center might need refinancing. The Kaka‘ako stake might be the right one to exit for liquidity. The ranch might be the one asset the family agrees, without much debate, they will never sell regardless of return.

A Practical Framework

Rather than starting with a Broker’s Opinion of Value for a portfolio, families achieve far better outcomes by starting with a short, honest set of questions – ideally with trustees, attorneys, accountants and real estate advisers in the room together, not consulted one at a time:

  1. PURPOSE. What is this family actually trying to accomplish over the next 20 to 30 years – income, growth, legacy or some deliberate mix of the three?
  2. LEGACY VERSUS INVESTMENT. Which properties are emotionally and culturally non-negotiable, and which have become financial holdings that happen to be real estate?
  3. LIQUIDITY. Does the family have enough accessible cash that no single member is compelled into a fire sale or a bitter buyout to meet a personal need?
  4. LEADERSHIP. Who in the next generation is actually prepared – and willing – to carry this responsibility forward, and are they being integrated into these conversations now, rather than after a crisis – like the sudden death of a patriarch – forces the issue?

None of these questions has a universal right answer. What matters is that the family answers them together, deliberately, before market pressure or a family emergency forces a decision under duress.

Stewardship, Redefined

For generations, stewardship in Hawaiʻi meant one thing: hold on. That instinct came from a real place – land here has always carried meaning beyond its balance-sheet value, and that has not changed.

But stewardship today also means something harder: being willing to sell, refinance or restructure a piece of the portfolio when doing so strengthens the family as a whole, rather than treating every parcel as equally sacred. The families who navigate this well are not the ones who hold everything indefinitely. They are the ones who know, asset by asset, which properties to protect at all costs – and which ones they can let go of in service of the family that is still here.

Categories: Community & Economy, Housing, Real Estate